CHESS ARCHIVES INDEX:

A:
Alice Chess (Dr. Egregious vs Taylor / Shane)
An Egregious Introduction (Dr. Egregious vs Shane, Dr. Egregious vs Taylor)
Aurora vs Wayne (AuroraDash vs Wayne)

C:
C. Seymour vs. Dr. Egregious: Contramatic Chess~♥ (Charlotte vs Dr. Egregious)
Cylindrical Chess (Taylor / Dianke / Wayne vs Shane / Dr. Egregious)

D:
Dr. Egregious versus Wayne (Dr. Egregious vs Wayne)

P:
Preliminary Chess Round: Shane vs KarjamP (Shane vs KarjamP)
Preliminary Chess Round: Shane vs Taylor (Shane vs Taylor)

S:
Shane vs Wayne (Shane vs Wayne)
Shane vs Wayne II (Shane vs Wayne)

T:
Taylor of Ziar Town versus the Doctor of Time (Taylor vs Dr. Time; unfinished)
Taylor vs Wayne (Taylor vs Wayne)

Um.
The winner(s) of each match are underlined.

I've done it.

Let's see...
Without Bulletin Board Code (BBCode), the first post would look like this.

---

[size=18pt][b]CHESS ARCHIVES INDEX:[/b][/size]

[b]A:[/b]
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/alice-chess/]Alice Chess[/url] ([u]Dr. Egregious[/u] vs Taylor / Shane)
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/an-egregious-introduction/]An Egregious Introduction[/url] ([u]Dr. Egregious[/u] vs Shane, [u]Dr. Egregious[/u] vs Taylor)
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/aurora-vs-wayne/]Aurora vs Wayne[/url] ([u]AuroraDash[/u] vs Wayne)

[b]C:[/b]
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/portal-chess-test/]Cylindrical Chess[/url] ([u]Taylor / Dianke / Wayne[/u] vs Shane / Dr. Egregious)

[b]D:[/b]
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/dr-egregious-versus-wayne/]Dr. Egregious versus Wayne[/url] ([u]Dr. Egregious[/u] vs Wayne)

[b]P:[/b]
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/preliminary-chess-round-shane-vs-karjamp/]Preliminary Chess Round: Shane vs KarjamP[/url] ([u]Shane[/u] vs KarjamP)
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/preliminary-chess-round-shane-vs-taylor/]Preliminary Chess Round: Shane vs Taylor[/url] ([u]Shane[/u] vs Taylor)

[b]S:[/b]
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/shane-vs-wayne/]Shane vs Wayne[/url] (Shane vs [u]Wayne[/u])
[url=http://shanescavestory.createaforum.com/chess-archives/shane-vs-wayne-ii/]Shane vs Wayne II[/url] (Shane vs [u]Wayne[/u])

---

Basically:
[url=The link of the match's first post]Thread name[/url] (Player 1 vs Player 2, with the victor being [u]underlined[/u])

Does that help?

If not, you could always try using the BBCode Testing Thread to try.